This is probably the final post I’m going to make about Threads unless something substantial changes.
Based on information I was given about the product just before launch, I had hoped – well, I’m not sure “hoped” is the right word, but maybe it is – that Threads would be something other than just a Twitter clone. That they were trying to build a system which would internally silo off bad actors, in the way that the Federation – Mastodon, et al – uses defederation to turn the Nazi Bar phenominon against Nazis.
While you can see evidence of this other platform that I considered possible, it’s clear that if that ever was the goal, a course-correction got applied once Musk started destroying Twitter. Zuckerberg wanted those users, and unlike the Federation’s 14 million or so, 300 million accounts isn’t scratch marks.
I’ve been watching – anonymously, through a browser view, christ no I’m not installing that app – and the usual crowd of fash all signed up on Threads, did a bunch of their usual crapping in the pool. A fair number but by no means all have since gone idle, possibly due to what looks like to me to be very, very low interaction rates. However, the vicious attacks on trans people, the nazi memes posted as threats, all of that has been allowed to stay up. How visible it is – how well it’s being shared or not shared – is an open question.
But it’s been allowed to stay up, regardless. There are unconfirmed reports that some fash accounts are being protected from user reports, and newtype blood libel like calling all LGBT people child molesters is allowed to stand. I read elsewhere that Meta/Facebook also said that the “this account posts disinformation” warnings that I reported a few days ago were accidental and have been removed, so that one somewhat hopeful sign is now gone.
However, there are supposedly over 100 million users on Threads already. Whether that’s actually true is a very good question, given reports of people finding their friends have Threads accounts, but who actually do not. They have Instagram accounts, and have never installed or tried to use Threads – but still show up as Threads users. Always remember: Facebook / Meta has a very long history of massive and complete lying about numbers, and this may be another case of that.
Regardless, the userbase is most likely actually substantial given the falloff in Twitter usage. There is some actual “there” there. As such, the press are coronating it as the Twitter Replacement.
Even if it apparently feels like some sort of cross between a shopping mall and the incarnation of depression – and I have to say that for me, even anonymously through a web browser, it’s felt really awful hanging out there, not as bad as Twitter but bad in the same way – people would rather be there than on a site where “verified” users with hundreds of thousands of users post explicitly anti-Semitic hate propaganda, and where people in replies post polls where most people answering say the Nazis were the good guys. People are tired of playing Elon’s Performative Dominance Game, so they’re moving on.
So. Me, I still say “join us in the Federation,” be it Mastodon or Calckey or Lemmy or one of the other services – it doesn’t matter, they all intercommunicate. What’ll happen – assuming you put in some effort and explore – is that about a week to ten days in you’ll suddenly take a deep breath and remember oh right, this shit used to be fun, that’s why we did it.
But if it’s only Twitter or Threads for you no matter what, pick Threads, solely because Musk’s plan to turn buy a social media platform into a fascist disinformation and propaganda fountain has to fail.
Just remember these warnings:
Or for the gods’ sakes, don’t. Just don’t. Remember who Mark Zuckerberg is, I beg you, and step back.
Seriously. It doesn’t have to be like this.
Walk away.
Let it all burn down.
Posted via Solarbird{y|z|yz}, Collected.