burn in hell, NPR
Apr. 17th, 2009 09:24 amSo the Bush administration torture memos that the ACLU sued to have released finally came out yesterday, and to the Obama administration's credit, they were not heavily redacted. To their shame, they promised no prosecutions of anyone involved.
Last night, after the memo reports broke, NPR referred directly and bluntly to the torture described within, and actually, directly used the word "torture," as do the memos themselves. I hoped, briefly, that this indicated that one particular lie - the lie of "harsh" or "enhanced" interrogation techniques - had been put aside.
I was wrong; this morning, as I was getting ready for the day, NPR was exclusively - and it seemed to me, pointedly - using the term "harsh interrogation techniques" again, and not using the word torture except in the usual "some describe it as" sort of way. Someone clearly got a memo, and that memo is that they, as the New York Times, as the Washington Post, and all the rest of that dying, wretched lot, will continue the pretence that torture is not torture if Americans do it. And their language will reflect that.
I don't know how you can do this and call yourself a journalist. I don't know how you can do that when one of the torture techniques is copied-and-pasted from the climatic white-room sequence in George Orwell's 1984 and not call it torture. (Substitute "rat" for "stinging insect" and it's exactly the same scene.) I don't know how you can have direct, positive, unassailable proof of the Bush administration and the United States Government stealing from the all-powerful supergovernment of Orwell and continue that lie.
I really don't.
Not to mention the whole waterboarding thing, the Nazi SS-perfected stress positions, the techniques borrowed from the Stalinists directly, and everything else described therein. And yet the sheep chorus brays on.
That last link is to the torture memos themselves. Greenwald's initial analysis here. Commentary on the slavish role of the political media in continuing the lie, here. Sullivan on the banality of bureaucratic evil, here.
eta: I had missed this - genuinely, I hadn't seen it - but I'm not the only one to catch the 1984 identity.
Last night, after the memo reports broke, NPR referred directly and bluntly to the torture described within, and actually, directly used the word "torture," as do the memos themselves. I hoped, briefly, that this indicated that one particular lie - the lie of "harsh" or "enhanced" interrogation techniques - had been put aside.
I was wrong; this morning, as I was getting ready for the day, NPR was exclusively - and it seemed to me, pointedly - using the term "harsh interrogation techniques" again, and not using the word torture except in the usual "some describe it as" sort of way. Someone clearly got a memo, and that memo is that they, as the New York Times, as the Washington Post, and all the rest of that dying, wretched lot, will continue the pretence that torture is not torture if Americans do it. And their language will reflect that.
I don't know how you can do this and call yourself a journalist. I don't know how you can do that when one of the torture techniques is copied-and-pasted from the climatic white-room sequence in George Orwell's 1984 and not call it torture. (Substitute "rat" for "stinging insect" and it's exactly the same scene.) I don't know how you can have direct, positive, unassailable proof of the Bush administration and the United States Government stealing from the all-powerful supergovernment of Orwell and continue that lie.
I really don't.
Not to mention the whole waterboarding thing, the Nazi SS-perfected stress positions, the techniques borrowed from the Stalinists directly, and everything else described therein. And yet the sheep chorus brays on.
That last link is to the torture memos themselves. Greenwald's initial analysis here. Commentary on the slavish role of the political media in continuing the lie, here. Sullivan on the banality of bureaucratic evil, here.
eta: I had missed this - genuinely, I hadn't seen it - but I'm not the only one to catch the 1984 identity.