Things are moving more quickly now
Mar. 10th, 2008 12:12 amOkay, so late Friday, things started to happen. As I'm posting this, it's already Monday in Asia, and the dollar is tanking again - new record lows, falling below 101 yen, .68 euros, all that. Bloomberg reports traders are expecting a Fed funds rate cut to 2%, which is well below a ZIRP at this point. We'll see what happens.
Much more interesting was the late-Friday boost in the TAF - kind of like the Fed discount window, only secret (now with extra opacity!) from US$60B to US$200B. That is a absolute Imperial assload of money, and is yet another attempt to restart credit markets and slow down margin-calling. Not easy. In particular Washington Mutual is thought to be in severe, severe trouble, and is begging for cash anywhere it can get it, leading some to worry about FDIC action. But they are not the only ones - the problem is starting to be recognised as systemic. Various sources describe this as the worst the markets have been in living memory:
The strains are showing up everywhere. Hedge funds are blocking withdrawals. Countrywide has another new problem: a reported Justice Department investigation. That's not going to calm anyone down or make any friends. As a reminder, in case you forgot, it's not just the US credit markets; the European LIBOR spreads are also rocketing up. Brad Setser at RGE Monitor has one word for the current situation: Grim. The New York Times had a widely-read article over the weekend noting that the entire post-2002 expansion proceeded without wage gains, and that most Americans are still making less than before 2000. And Paul Krugman asks what's to be done, quoting some interesting testimony from the president of the New York Fed. (Sadly, Krugman's interpretation is... reasonable.)
And several people have linked to this analysis, which calls the Fed actions "covert nationalization, describing the Fed as "Wall Street's genial pawnbroker." I like this section:
(ETA: My contrarian sense is going off a bit. If this weren't of such scale and so systematic (and we weren't clearly in a recession already) this is right about where I'd be looking for things to get better. But it really is that kind of bad. So, well, yeah. Messy and random!)
Much more interesting was the late-Friday boost in the TAF - kind of like the Fed discount window, only secret (now with extra opacity!) from US$60B to US$200B. That is a absolute Imperial assload of money, and is yet another attempt to restart credit markets and slow down margin-calling. Not easy. In particular Washington Mutual is thought to be in severe, severe trouble, and is begging for cash anywhere it can get it, leading some to worry about FDIC action. But they are not the only ones - the problem is starting to be recognised as systemic. Various sources describe this as the worst the markets have been in living memory:
''We are in historic scarier-than-all hell territory,'' said T.J. Marta, an analyst who monitors the fixed-income markets for RBC Capital Markets. ''I am hearing many people say that the market is more broken now than it ever has been.''As crazy as they already are, it's not getting any saner yet - MBIA, one of the monoline insurers everyone is trying to pretend is still credit-worthy, asked the one rating agency which downgraded it at all to stop publishing ratings on them! I mean what the hell, people?! The credibility of these rating agencies is truly destroyed at this point. Mish (previous link) opines:
I like this solution actually, provided it would be carried to the logical conclusion: Moody's, Fitch, and the S&P should all lose government monopoly sponsorship. The big three rating agencies are clearly unqualified to rate anything. The conflicts of interest are stunning. They should all stop simultaneously.He also notes separately that the credit markets are in a panic for the third time.
The strains are showing up everywhere. Hedge funds are blocking withdrawals. Countrywide has another new problem: a reported Justice Department investigation. That's not going to calm anyone down or make any friends. As a reminder, in case you forgot, it's not just the US credit markets; the European LIBOR spreads are also rocketing up. Brad Setser at RGE Monitor has one word for the current situation: Grim. The New York Times had a widely-read article over the weekend noting that the entire post-2002 expansion proceeded without wage gains, and that most Americans are still making less than before 2000. And Paul Krugman asks what's to be done, quoting some interesting testimony from the president of the New York Fed. (Sadly, Krugman's interpretation is... reasonable.)
And several people have linked to this analysis, which calls the Fed actions "covert nationalization, describing the Fed as "Wall Street's genial pawnbroker." I like this section:
What we are witnessing is an incremental, partial nationalization of the US banking system. Northern Rock in the UK is peanuts compared to what the New York Fed is up to.Market Ticker has a new open letter in response to all that that he's inviting other people to sign and send in themselves. You might give it a read.
You may object, and I'm sure many of you will, that our little thought experiment is bunk, debt is debt and equity is equity, these are 28-day loans, and that's that. But notionally collateralized "term" loans that won't ever be redeemed unless and until it is convenient for borrowers are an odd sort of liability. ...
I do not, by the way, object to nationalizing failing banks. There are (unfortunately) banks that are "too big to fail", whose abrupt disappearance could cause widespread disruption and harm. These should be nationalized when they fall to the brink. But they should be nationalized overtly, their equity written to zero, and their executives shamed. That sounds harsh. It is harsh. One hates to see bad things happen to nice people, and these are mostly nice people. But running institutions with trillion-dollar balance sheets is a serious business. Accountability matters. These people were not stupid. They knew, in Chuck Prince's now infamous words, that "when the music stops... things will be complicated.", and they kept dancing anyway.
(ETA: My contrarian sense is going off a bit. If this weren't of such scale and so systematic (and we weren't clearly in a recession already) this is right about where I'd be looking for things to get better. But it really is that kind of bad. So, well, yeah. Messy and random!)