Suggested reading
Feb. 22nd, 2007 09:27 pmHere, you'll want to read this article in The American Conservative1: The Fall of Modernity: Has the American narrative authored its own undoing? (Andrew Sullivan linked to it earlier today.) Despite the paleoconservative slant, in my first reading I think it's one of the better statements of how the Endless War works to wreck both American culture and actively works against its supposed - or, at least, stated - goals. I agree strongly with some of the author's conclusions (legitimisation, elevation, narrative) and disagree strongly on others (can narrative be changed, is there a meaningful policy path that could be effective in the longer term, several others to smaller degrees)2. A few key areas, I think, are left inadequately considered - he does not call out torture explicitly, and I think arguably fails in ignoring the question of control over oil... but the former rolls up into the rest of the point, and the latter could easily be a sound goal he considers to have been subverted.
Anyway, I have some relevant thoughts of my own in relation to this article about the role of energy, population - in particular, control over reproduction - and the spread of rational thoughtwhich this margin is too small to contain, but which I will attempt to describe after my biology midterm.
Here's the first paragraph of the article; I recommend clicking through for the rest.
1: No, I'm not a fan of the magazine, and particularly I'm not a fan of its demifascist asshat co-founder, Pat Buchanan. You know it's gotten pretty bad when I'm linking to his former magazine.
2: If you think about the paleoconservative blind spots, you should be able to extrapolate most of these out - as well as some of the things I don't have time for right now.
Anyway, I have some relevant thoughts of my own in relation to this article about the role of energy, population - in particular, control over reproduction - and the spread of rational thought
Here's the first paragraph of the article; I recommend clicking through for the rest.
The Fall of Modernity
Has the American narrative authored its own undoing?
February 26, 2007 Issue
Copyright © 2006 The American Conservative
by Michael Vlahos
http://www.amconmag.com/2007/2007_02_12/feature.html
We are losing our wars in the Muslim world because our vision of history is at odds with reality. This is a well-established condition of successful societies, a condition that inevitably grows more worrisome with time and continuing success. In fact, what empires have most in common is how their sacred narratives come to rule their strategic behavior—and rule it badly. In America’s case, our war narrative works against us to promote our deepest fear: the end of modernity.
1: No, I'm not a fan of the magazine, and particularly I'm not a fan of its demifascist asshat co-founder, Pat Buchanan. You know it's gotten pretty bad when I'm linking to his former magazine.
2: If you think about the paleoconservative blind spots, you should be able to extrapolate most of these out - as well as some of the things I don't have time for right now.